Mixtape
Best for players who want a short, music-driven narrative experience over traditional gameplay.
Where creators disagree
Luke Stephens likes the narrative-first approach, but
Asmongold says it barely counts as a game.
Reviews
The creator clearly reviews Mixtape based on personal play, calling it really good, fun, and highly recommendable. He praises the sharply written story, snappy dialogue, engaging character delivery, and phenomenal music, while noting that gameplay takes a back seat because it is primarily a narrative experience.
May 10, 2026
The creator spends the whole video giving first impressions of Mixtape, praising its music integration, presentation, writing, atmosphere, pacing, and emotional coming-of-age story while noting that the gameplay is extremely simple and one voice performance weakens a few scenes. Overall he came away pleasantly surprised and recommends it for people who enjoy short, story-driven games.
May 8, 2026
The creator is clearly criticizing Mixtape and mocking the very high review scores it received. They argue that critics are overpraising the game mainly because of its licensed soundtrack rather than the developers' own work, suggesting the praise is undeserved.
May 14, 2026
Asmongold spends a substantial part of the video discussing Mixtape and strongly agrees with criticisms of it, repeatedly saying it is 'not even a game' and condemning it as an interactive movie with little real gameplay. His core assessment is that Mixtape is bad, overly cinematic, cringe, and part of a broader trend of story-heavy 'game movies' that he finds exhausting and unfun to play.
May 24, 2026
Earlier coverage
May 11, 2026
Gameranx